If you’ve ever had a doctor dismiss your pain (“medical gaslighting”), know that you’re not alone. Research has found that many don’t receive the standard quality of care when it comes to pain.
Key Takeaways:
-
Women, people of color, and people in the LGBTQ+ community experience heightened rates of medical gaslighting
-
Medical gaslighting may be caused by overwhelmed doctors relying on flawed mental shortcuts, internal bias, and misinformed medical practices
-
The best ways to deal with medical gaslighting include preparing notes on your symptoms and questions, asking for a differential diagnosis, and bringing a friend. (More tips below.)
“Anxiety can have lots of physical symptoms. Have you been feeling anxious recently?”
Sara felt deflated. She’d barely started listing her symptoms when her doctor cut her off.
She knew what anxiety felt like. This was different.
She tried again, “I hear what you’re saying. But this pain has been for 2 months now and it’s really impacting my ability to function. I —”
He interrupts, “again, it’s probably stress or anxiety. I suggest managing your stress more intentionally for a few weeks and then we can meet back to discuss how things are going. Try going for 20-minute walks and meditating.”
Before she knew it, her doctor was walking out the door and their appointment was over.
Where was Sara in a few weeks? Still struggling to make it through her days with pain.

Unfortunately, Sara’s story is not unique. It’s been experienced by people from all walks of life, but in particular by women, people of color, and the LGBTQIA+ community. And it’s been widely dubbed as a practice called “medical gaslighting.”
Going to the doctor to share your pain is a vulnerable experience. It becomes doubly painful to open up and have your symptoms dismissed as “all in your head” or “your fault.” You know your body best. If you’re in pain, you deserve to have that pain taken seriously.
In this article, we’ll explore what medical gaslighting is, what causes it, who’s most likely to experience it, and how you can deal with it.

What is Medical Gaslighting?
The term “gaslighting” comes from a 1938 play called Gas Light, where a husband tries to make his wife doubt her sanity and ability to trust in her senses.
“Medical gaslighting” depicts a similar scenario, where patients are made to believe their symptoms aren’t real, are in their head, or are their own fault.

Some easy-to-spot red flags of medical gaslighting include your doctor:
-
Interrupting or cutting you off
-
Not listening to you
-
Not taking your symptoms seriously
-
Laughing at your concerns
-
Blaming you for your symptoms
-
Suggesting your symptoms are all in your head
-
Suggesting the cause of your medical issue is mental health
Mental health and lifestyle habits like nutrition, movement, self-care, and self-talk can play a role in health and pain.
Cumulatively, they can play quite important roles. But these should never be the only diagnosis your physician offers.
You know what pain is normal versus what isn’t. If you’re in enough pain to go to the doctor, the physician should always take it seriously and consider all potential causes.
If your doctor dismisses your pain entirely as mental health or lifestyle-related, that’s a sign of medical gaslighting.

Who’s Most Likely to Receive Subpar Pain Care?
People of all demographics experience medical gaslighting. In fact, a survey by Health Central found >94% of respondents had experienced doctors dismissing or ignoring their symptoms.1
However, research has shown that certain communities experience higher rates of medical gaslighting and poorer medical care than others.

Women Experience More Medical Gaslighting
Research found that women showing identical symptoms of heart disease as men were twice as likely to receive a mental health diagnosis instead of a heart disease diagnosis.2
One study with 4,000+ participants found significant differences in the treatment for brain trauma injuries women received compared to men. Women were less likely to be admitted to the ICU than men, had shorter median stays in the hospital, and had worse outcomes in mental health, more severe post-concussion symptoms, and worse symptoms six months later.3
Research similarly found that women experienced a longer time until diagnosis for six non-gender-specific cancers.4
Another study found that amongst young adults who presented with chest pain at the emergency department, women were less likely to be triaged with acute symptom severity, be given an EKG, or to be sent to the hospital.11

People of Color and Medical Gaslighting
People of color, and specifically women of color, similarly receive poorer quality of care.
For example, researchers found that overloaded physicians were less likely to prescribe pain medication to black patients than to white patients. 5
In reviewing over 9,000 doctor notes in a clinic, bioethicist Dr. Mary Catherine Beach and internal medicine physician Dr. Somnath Saha found increased expression of disbelief of black patients’ symptoms. This included quotation marks around symptoms or words in the doctor’s notes (which conveys doubt about the patient’s symptoms), along with judgment words that expressed doubt (e.g., “claims” or “insists”).6
Other studies have found that black patients are more likely to be labeled with stigmatizing negative descriptor language (e.g.,“uncooperative”), which was linked with more negative attitudes towards the patient and less aggressive management of the patient’s pain.7, 8
A final study of 12,000+ outpatients with irregular heartbeats found that black patients were 25% less likely to be given oral anti-blood thinners that help prevent clots. They were also 37% less likely to be prescribed the newer, safer, and easier-to-use anticoagulant.9
The LGBTQIA+ Community and Medical Gaslighting
A new study released this year found significant differences in the medical experiences of LGBTQIA+ patients and heterosexual, cisgender individuals. The survey included 952 LGBTQIA+ respondents and 1,049 heterosexual cisgender respondents. Results included:
- 47% of LGBTQIA+ patients reported medical gaslighting compared to 26% of heterosexual cisgender patients
- 18% LGBTQIA+ respondents reported experiencing medical trauma
- 10% reported experiencing medical discrimination10
The Impact of Medical Gaslighting
Medical gaslighting is a painful, invalidating experience that can be traumatizing for patients already living with the daily fatigue and frustration of chronic pain.
But medical gaslighting can also have dangerous repercussions by leading to longer times to diagnosis, less aggressive pain management, longer-lasting pain, and worse health outcomes.
What Causes this Disparity in Health Care?
As harsh as the experience can feel, most doctors aren’t intending to deliver worse treatment for women, people of color, and people in the LGBTQIA+ community. It may come down to overworked doctors who aren’t allowed much beyond 15 minutes per patient and end up relying on mental shortcuts, misinformed beliefs (e.g., black people have higher pain tolerances, which is untrue), and unconscious internalized bias.
This is not an excuse for the poor care that some medical professionals provide people with pain. Every person deserves to have their symptoms taken seriously.
But because most doctors who do this are simply operating on automatic, there are several ways you can advocate for yourself when seeking medical care.
How to Deal with or Avoid Medical Gaslighting
1. Keep Notes on Your Symptoms
Patient advocacy begins with expressing yourself loud and clear. Of course, this is easier said than done when you’re 1:1 with a doctor. Sometimes it’s hard to say everything you want to. So take careful notes to help lay out the big picture in a way that makes doctors take it seriously.Consider taking notes that include:
- The time each episode occurs
- How long each episode lasts
- Description and location of the pain
- The peak and average severity of the pain from 1-10 (Here’s our chronic pain scale for reference)
- Any patterns in timing or triggers
- What you’ve already tried to manage it
Try to also take notes during your appointment, so you can refer to everything that was said in future communications.

2. Prepare a List of Questions
When doctors get dismissive, it’s hard to stay on track. Keep in mind that you’re there to solve your pain, not to make their days easier. Write down a list of questions you want to ask (like those in our next tip!)
3. Ask for a Differential Diagnosis (DDx)
This is a great tip we picked up from Dr. Dorender Gray. If your doctor dismisses your symptoms, ask them for a differential diagnosis (DDx). A differential diagnosis is a practice doctors do that involves listing out all possible causes for a set of symptoms.
Begin by asking your doctor, “What’s my differential diagnosis for [symptoms]?”
Once they list all your options, go one option at a time and ask them, “How did you rule out this one for me?”
It if wasn’t ruled out, ask them, “What’s the evidence for and against this one?”
These questions will force your doctor to really consider your symptoms and give all your options.
(We love this tip by Dr. Gray! You can check out more of her insights @Dor_the_grayt )
4. Insist on Noting Refusals in Your Chart
If the doctor doesn’t have a way to rule out a possible diagnosis, and doesn’t have good evidence that it’s not the case, ask, “What tests could be run to rule this one out?”
Ask if the test carries any risks, so you can make an informed decision.
If you want the test, ask for it. If the doctor says no, say, “OK. Please note my request and your refusal in my chart. I’ll wait while you note it.”
If they don’t want to, insist. This can be uncomfortable, but it’s your right. Don’t let them note it after you leave (and maybe forget to do so), sit there and watch them do it.
The reason for all this is simple: Noting that they refused to order the test creates liability for the doctor. Usually, when pressed to note their refusal, doctors will change their mind and order the test.

5. Bring a Trusted Friend
Talking with doctors can be intimidating. If you feel comfortable, ask a loved one to come with you. They can be great sources of support to help you feel more confident sharing your experience and advocating for yourself. They can also help validate your symptoms and offer testimony about how they aren’t normal for you. Your loved ones may come up with questions you don’t think to ask.
6. Trust Your GutY
ou know if you’re in pain and if that pain’s normal. If your doctor isn’t taking your pain seriously and you don’t trust them — get a 2nd opinion, a 3rd opinion, and even a 4th opinion if you need to. Trust is fundamental to the care provider-patient team. Don’t settle for someone you don’t trust. There are good doctors out there who’ll take your pain seriously.

Explore more tips to deal with medical gaslighting here >>
We hope this guide helps as you explore options along your healing journey! If you’re looking for more holistic support with your chronic pain, we’d love to help. Just send us a message and we’ll get back to you as soon as we can.



